Food

Are Canned Foods Healthy? Examining Their Pros and Cons

·
·
9 min read
Summary

Canned foods sure are convenient, but are they healthy? Does canning destroy nutrients in foods? Does the packaging contain dangerous chemicals, and if so, can you avoid them? And how long can you safely keep canned goods in your pantry? This article gives you the truth about canned foods.

One of my favorite fun facts is that it took over 40 years after the invention of the tin can for someone to come up with the can opener. A French chef, Nicolas Appert, discovered how to preserve food in airtight containers; first glass, then tin-lined iron. These cans turned out to solve the problem of how to feed Napoleon’s troops as they marched across Europe and his sailors as they cruised the Caribbean.

The problem was that there was no easy way to get the food out. So French soldiers ended up stabbing the cans with knives and bayonets (and sometimes shooting them with rifles) to access their dinner. Not very safe — or hygienic.

These days, with the advent of manual and electric can openers and pop-top lids, canned food often beats fresh when it comes to ease, convenience, and sometimes even food safety. But what about nutrition? Are canned foods good or bad for you? How do you best store them? And what should you look for to ensure you get the healthiest canned food items?

What Are Canned Foods?

BARCELONA, SPAIN - JUNE 4, 2018: Image of shelves with variety products in cans in the supermarket
istock.com/JackF

Any food sterilized and preserved by heat treatment in hermetically sealed (airtight) containers, and thus made shelf-stable, is canned food. Just as the processing of French military rations made them last longer, modern canning practices preserve otherwise perishable foods.

This allows them to be shipped over long distances without wilting or spoiling and makes them shelf-stable for months, if not years or even decades.

Some canned foods are ultra-processed (think Spam and SpaghettiOs). But other canned foods, such as tomatoes and beans, are considered minimally processed foods.

The UN Food and Agriculture Organization’s NOVA classification system lumps unprocessed and minimally processed foods together, defining the category as “edible parts of plants or animals that have been taken straight from nature or that have been minimally modified/preserved.” These foods retain most of their original nutritional value and are often preserved using simple methods like water, brine, or natural juices.

So canned foods can range from highly processed convenience products to wholesome, minimally altered staple foods. Understanding this range helps clarify that “canned food” doesn’t automatically equate to unhealthy.

Are Canned Foods Good for You?

Let’s start with the other benefits of canned food before exploring whether it offers any nutritional advantages.

Canned food is convenient. Much of it is ready-to-prepare (or even ready-to-eat, if you picture people eating beans or canned chili by a campfire).

Food that’s been canned lasts a really long time. Many canned products have a shelf life of one to five years, which helps minimize food waste.

And canned food is cost-effective, too. The fact that it doesn’t need to be transported or stored in a fridge or freezer translates into real savings for the consumer.

When seasonal produce isn’t available, canned food can offer year-round variety to your diet. This can fill food and nutrient gaps in regions where growing a wide variety of foods is difficult.

Now, let’s talk about canned food nutrition. On the positive side, fruits and vegetables are often picked at peak ripeness and canned shortly after harvesting. And the modern canning process leaves many nutrients, including minerals, fat-soluble vitamins, protein, fat, and carbohydrates relatively unchanged. What’s more, the heating process may increase the bioavailability of some antioxidants, such as lycopene in tomatoes.

This means that canned foods can provide nutritious options for a balanced diet. A 2007 study compared frozen, fresh, and canned foods and found that all three offered comparable nutritional benefits. Some nutrients, like carotenoids, were actually higher in canned foods than their fresh counterparts.

A 2015 study also found that people who ate a lot of canned foods got more of 17 essential nutrients, including potassium, calcium, and fiber, than infrequent consumers of canned foods.

Canned Foods’ Bad Side

Woman buying groceries at the supermarket, she is holding a can and checking the food label
istock.com/demaerre

Canned foods aren’t without their negatives and cautions, however.

Many foods degrade in flavor and texture when they’re canned. I know many people who, to this day, hate peas, green beans, and spinach because their first exposure to these wonderful veggies was from a can.

And while many nutrients remain, water-soluble vitamins may be lost due to the high heat required to kill pathogens during the canning process. That means you may get fewer of these vitamins, including the all-important C and B vitamins.

Plus, to restate the obvious, not all canned foods are healthy. Some are obviously ultra-processed. Exhibit A: May I present Cheeseburger in a Can?

But even healthy-sounding items, like baked beans, may be swimming in a puddle of added sugar, salt, and preservatives.

If you’re canning your own food, there’s also the risk of mold growth or bacterial contamination. Make sure to follow home canning guidelines to avoid foodborne illness.

And while commercially canned foods are highly unlikely to give you botulism or salmonella, there are some real concerns about packaging safety. The BPA linings of traditional cans, exposure to aluminum, and potential leaching of other chemical contaminants used in can linings have been linked to health problems.

BPA and Canned Foods

When people talk about canned foods, BPA is one of the top concerns. Modern aluminum cans typically have a lining to prevent corrosion, changes in taste, and bacterial contamination. For decades, one of the most common can linings contained a plastic chemical called BPA (short for bisphenol A).

The CDC’s 2008 National Health and Nutrition Examination Survey revealed that over 90% of US consumers had detectable BPA in their urine. This finding sparked a flurry of research into whether this stuff was harming us.

Here’s what we’ve learned: BPA that leaches into foods and drinks from BPA-lined cans is an endocrine disruptor and may even contribute to cancer development. BPA exposure may also be linked to behavioral problems in children. Furthermore, some research points to a potential connection between BPA and type 2 diabetes and even heart disease.

As a result, many canned food manufacturers say they have gradually phased out BPA linings. A trade group for the canned food industry claims that most cans do not contain BPA anymore. But recent studies have concluded that it’s still in use and exposes people to harmful health effects. As a result, the European Commission recently banned BPA in food-contact packaging.

Although many BPA-free alternatives are now in use, the long-term safety of alternative can-lining materials — including acrylic, polyester, PVC (polyvinyl chloride), and oleoresins — is still being studied. Some researchers suggest that some of these alternatives could also leach endocrine-disrupting chemicals into food.

One promising replacement for BPA, oleoresinous enamel, is a mixture of oil and resin extracted from plants such as pine or balsam fir. It could be the safest option (although more study is needed). Unfortunately, it doesn’t work for highly acidic foods like tomatoes.

Tips for Safer and Healthier Canned Foods

Canned green lentils displaying the contents amount of calories, fat, saturates, sugar and salt
istock.com/HotHibiscus

To help you choose the best canned foods for your health, here are some tips from the Environmental Working Group on buying canned food:

  • Look for that BPA-free label. If the label doesn’t say, contact the company to ask what chemicals they use in their can liners.
  • Avoid purchasing canned foods that are highly acidic, like tomato, citrus, or pineapple, since liner toxins are more prone to leaching into acidic foods. Instead, get these foods in a glass container or choose frozen options.
  • Reduce your exposure to BPA and other potentially harmful chemicals by including a variety of fresh and frozen foods in addition to canned.
  • Look for low-sodium, no-salt-added, and no-added-sugar options. Opt for fruit canned in its juice or water instead of syrup. Choose savory foods canned in water or brine rather than oil.
  • Look for organic canned foods to minimize your consumption of pesticides and additives.
  • Avoid dented, rusted, or otherwise damaged cans to prevent bacterial contamination.

How To Store Canned Foods

Store canned goods in a cool, dry place where the temperature is below 85 F (50–70 F is ideal). For you metric folks, that’s below 30 C, with 10–21 C as the sweet spot.

Practice the FIFO rule. No, this has nothing to do with an international soccer federation. It stands for “First In, First Out,” meaning you use the oldest cans first rather than letting them gather dust in the back of your pantry. And abide by the “best by” date stamped on the can.

Store unused food from a can in an airtight container in the refrigerator or freezer, not in the original can. Why? Because once opened, the metal from the can may leach into the food and affect its taste, quality, and safety.

According to Food Republic, leftover canned beans and coconut milk can be stored in the freezer for up to 6 months. Thanks to their high acidity, leftover canned tomatoes can be stored in the freezer for up to a year.

Best Practices for Incorporating Whole Canned Foods into Your Diet

Aquafaba, chickpea water brine draining. Replace egg for vegan recipe
istock.com/Olga Chzhu

It’s always good practice to read nutrition labels for packaged foods, and canned foods are no exception. If a canned food is high in sodium, it’s a good idea to rinse and drain it using a colander or sieve — especially if you’re on a sodium-restricted diet.

If the sodium content is low (you can check the label — the US Food and Drug Administration considers anything below 140 grams of sodium per serving to be “low sodium”), you may want to include the canned liquid in your cooking. Doing so can minimize food waste while enhancing the flavors in a dish.

The liquid from canned beans is starchy and can be used as a thickening agent for soups, stews, and sauces, and even as a substitute for broth. The liquid from canned chickpeas, in particular, (also known as aquafaba — “bean water” in Italian), can be used to make vegan meringue-style toppings for desserts or as an egg white substitute in baking.

Another reason not to drain away the liquid in cans is that it may contain water-soluble vitamins and minerals that would otherwise be lost. The liquid from canned vegetables and beans can be stored in a glass jar in the refrigerator for up to three days or frozen for up to three months.

Pair canned foods with fresh foods to balance nutrition, flavors, and textures. For example, canned beans and beets go well in a fresh green salad. You can also use canned veggies, beans, and fruits in soups, stews, grain bowls, and smoothies.

Recipes Using Canned Foods

Canned foods don’t have to mean compromise. These healthy, flavor-packed recipes highlight how a few simple pantry picks — like canned beans, pumpkin, jackfruit, and hearts of palm — can turn into dishes that feel anything but ordinary.

Whether you’re craving something cool and zesty, warm and comforting, or sweet and tropical, these recipes make canned ingredients shine.

1. Aguachili Verde

This refreshing Aguachile Verde makes the most of pantry power, featuring canned hearts of palm in place of seafood for a light yet satisfying plant-based twist. Tossed with crisp cucumber, radish, and creamy avocado, the real magic comes from a punchy salsa verde blended with lime, cilantro, and chilies.

Want even more convenience? Swap in canned jalapeños for the fresh — it’s quicker, tangier, and just as bold. Proof that canned ingredients can bring vibrant, fresh flavor to the table in a way that’s healthy, simple, and seriously delicious.

2. Hearty Pumpkin Chili

Hearty Pumpkin Chili

This one-pot wonder is what cozy evenings are made for. This chili is spiced just right and layered with the natural richness of canned pumpkin, diced tomatoes, and protein-packed black beans. It’s hearty without being heavy, with zesty lime and a sprinkle of fresh toppings like avocado and pepitas for balance.

Nearly everything comes from a can or pantry staple in this recipe, making this Hearty Pumpkin Chili as practical as it is comforting. Canned convenience has never tasted so warm and satisfying.

3. Tropical Jackfruit Popsicles

Tropical Jackfruit Popsicles

These creamy, dreamy Tropical Jackfruit Popsicles turn canned jackfruit and light coconut milk into a tropical treat that feels indulgent but is refreshingly simple. Blended with mango and a splash of lime, they’re naturally sweet, tangy, and full of fruity sunshine.

Jackfruit is a tropical fruit rich in vitamin C, potassium, dietary fiber, and B vitamins, making it a nutrient-dense choice for refreshing summer treats like these popsicles. Vitamin C supports immune health, potassium helps regulate blood pressure, and fiber contributes to digestive health — all while adding natural sweetness and texture to your frozen dessert.

No peeling, chopping, or fancy equipment required — just a blender and a freezer.

With canned fruit doing the heavy lifting, this is a healthy dessert you’ll want on repeat.

Be Wise With Canned Foods

Canned foods can offer nutrient-dense, economical, and wholesome options and expand variety when fresh or frozen aren’t available or affordable. When selecting canned foods, consider the packaging and check ingredient labels to ensure you’re not getting unwanted chemicals or additives.

Aim for BPA-free cans or glass containers and avoid highly acidic canned foods like tomato and pineapple unless they’re in glass.

Stocking your pantry with canned foods is an excellent way to have nutrient-packed plant-based foods readily available for quick and easy plant-powered meals, and to help you maintain a healthy and balanced plant-based lifestyle.

Tell us in the comments:

  • Have you ever canned your own food?
  • Do you use canned foods in your cooking?

Read Next:

Featured image: istock.com/CatLane

  • Yes, I can my own beans and tomatoes. I have enjoyed canning over the last 4 years. I still buy canned beans and tomatoes as a backup. But much prefer canning. I’ve never saved the juice or brine, which was interesting to read of the nutritional value in the brine/juice.

  • We bought ourselves a pressure canner before Christmas. I’ve done kidney beans so far. It was easy and inexpensive. I’m very sure that the canner will pay for itself very quickly. And the beans were tasty, a nice texture, and salt free too.

  • Great question, Joanne, and a really fair point that deserves a clear explanation! There are a few important reasons why foods packed in oil are generally not recommended on a whole food plant based approach to heart health.

    First and most importantly, oils are essentially ultra processed foods — even the most celebrated ones like olive oil. When you extract oil from a whole food like an olive or a sunflower seed you are stripping away all of the fiber, protein and most of the beneficial nutrients, leaving behind a pure concentrated fat that is extremely calorie dense with very little nutritional value relative to those calories.

    From a cardiovascular standpoint specifically, oils including the ones used for packing foods damage the endothelium — that critically important delicate inner lining of your blood vessels — and this endothelial dysfunction is sometimes at the very root of heart disease. Dr. Esselstyn’s landmark research was very clear on this point, recommending zero added oils for anyone serious about reversing or preventing heart disease.

    When foods like tuna or vegetables are packed in oil you are also inevitably consuming a meaningful amount of that oil along with the food, even if you drain it, as the oil penetrates the food during the packing process.

    It is also worth mentioning that from a whole food plant based perspective fish is not recommended both for health reasons including mercury and microplastic contamination, and for the environmental impact of fishing. Whole plant based sources of omega 3s like flax, chia, hemp and algae oil are much cleaner alternatives.

    We hope that clarifies things! –Ina, Food Revolution Network Team

  • I buy Genova Tuna, which is packed in olive oil. I would think that would be a healthier option

  • Hello MaryAnn! Thank you for the question.

    Aseptic packaging is generally considered safer than traditional cans because it typically does not contain BPA or other can lining chemicals that can leach into acidic foods like tomatoes. The aseptic process involves rapidly heating and cooling food before sealing it in sterile packaging, which actually preserves nutrients really well — often better than traditional canning. The packaging is also lighter and more environmentally friendly to transport than glass or metal, and the cartons are recyclable in many areas.

    On the con side, aseptic cartons are made from multiple layers of materials including paperboard, plastic and a thin layer of aluminum, which makes them more complex to recycle than glass and not accepted by all recycling programs. They are not completely plastic free as there is a thin plastic lining inside, though the exposure risk is considered significantly lower than with traditional cans. Some cartons may also contain small amounts of BPA in that inner lining depending on the brand, though most have now moved away from this.

    The bottom line is that aseptic packaging is a genuinely good option and a significant step up from traditional cans for acidic foods like tomatoes and broths. It is not quite as ideal as glass but it is a very reasonable and practical choice for everyday shopping — so keep using it with confidence! –Ina, Food Revolution Network Team

  • I buy a lot of canned goods from Costco now that the health food store I used stopped selling beans in bulk. Because Goya is cheaper than organic and is the brand Costco sells, I stock up with thatll. Reading your article triggered my curiosity. Nowhere does it say BPA-free, even though often those are replaced with others that are almost as bad. I did notice the high sodium count, too. Red kidney beans have 330 mg, chickpeas 340, and black beans whopping 410 per serving. It leaves one wondering how much rinsing is required to lower those numbers, and how much sodium are you really getting rid of. Maybe everyone should start bean farms!

  • I hope you are safely canning with a pressure canner for non-acidic vegetables/ foods, including meats. Even with the long times published in old guides, boiling water does not exceed the boiling temperature as is needed to destroy botulism. It takes pressure to ensure higher temperatures.

  • Pasta sauces can be found in glass. I no longer buy the cans of this product, but do resort to canned tomato products sometimes to thicken sauces.

  • It is now exposed to air, and the chemistry changes as to what the food/ metal interaction could do. It is also no longer under a vacuum situation for pressure.

  • For many years I have gotten the regular pumpkins used for decoration, jack-o-latern size, and canned them in glass jars. This makes wonderful pies, cakes, bread, and soups, also pasta dishes. Very economical when the pumpkins are free from friends or discounted at the store after Halloween! I do correctly use a pressure canner. Knowing how to also do water bath canning, I have canned many foods in glass over a period going back about 40 years. I have even canned satsumas, like Mandarin oranges. And you cannot find full-flavored prickly pear jelly in any store like what I process.

  • I don’t quite understand why leaving an open can of food (covered with saran wrap) in the fridge would then leach bad things into the food, if it isn’t when not open.

  • Oil used is primarily seed oil; toxic because of Linoleic Acid. Also may contain Glyphosate, esp. with soybean oil.

  • I have canned for 25 years and dehydrate (love to do mushrooms for mushroom powder to make gravy). Right now I have celery in my dehydrator and got a freeze dryer last year that needs to be put into action this summer for my grandkids snacks!

  • Yes, I can many foods every year since we have a robust garden. My favorite is my mom’s recipe for tomato juice cocktail with tomatoes, onions, celery, just a wee bit of sugar to temper the acidity, a few shakes of Tabasco, lemon juice, fresh horseradish and Worcestershire sauce. I can it up in quarts and it’s WAY better than V8!

  • I buy tomato passata in tetra packs. Is that better than using canned passata? Or is there leaching from the tetra pack lining?

  • I use canned foods mostly in winter. Especially if cannot get out of the house but its mostly soups pacific or amys . Also add my own kale thats home grown and frozen so use when needed .

  • Yes, I have canned tomatoes, homemade spaghetti sauce, green beans, applesauce, and many jams. Except for a few jars which have come unsealed during storage I am very happy with these items and use them in our meals for the entire year.
    I have a question about why you don’t recommend buying foods packed in oil? There was no mention of why in your article. I buy tuna fish in oil. Thank you for an informative article.

  • I do use canned chopped tomatoes, black or kidney beans and chick peas. I guess that canning containers have developed through the years and are now safer then it was when I was a kid?
    The article was very informative 👏

  • Deterioration with time varys a lot depending on the food and the storage temperature though stored below 70F they are OK well beyond the use by date.. Some stored in glass look fine at 10 years but unsafe at 20 years. Others look good but don’t seem very nutritive or tasty.

  • pineapple has historically been in galvanized rather than plastic coated cans so there is no plastic to leach but they need to be stored in glass after opening because the can + pineapple will react with oxygen.

  • What evidence do you have that BPA replacements are safer. After working at a can company I believe otherwise.

  • Wonderfully enlightening. But, what about canned soups i.e. Trader Joe’s Chicken Noodle Soup?

  • Yes, I use mostly fresh vegetables but a few frozen, canned and jarred ones. I do have canned tomatoes and tomato sauce in my pantry. I get jarred tomatoes paste and beans when they are on sale or when I am at a store that has them. I use fresh and frozen fruit+ a little that is dried and then soaked in hot water before eating. Appreciate d your article.

  • I bring canned food when I’m on outdoor adventures, so I don’t resort to McDonald’s and Taco Bell. When you don’t know how long you’ll be and whether they will keep, canned is a great option.

  • I keep a lot of canned foods on the shelf as they are convenient. I also home-can foods in mason jars.
    I buy a lot of beans, tomatoes, tomato sauce and paste in cans. The convenience is why and I buy on sale.
    I also buy some fruits in cans.
    I do rotate cans and canned goods as I write the date I buy/make them on the top with a magic marker (my grandparents always did this back in the 1960’s and up, though I am sure as long as there were markers they did this).
    I’ve eaten canned foods 10 years or more past their “use by” dates and nothing wrong with them at all. As long as the can has not been compromised and when opened does not emit a lot of gas (a large “burp”) then I use them.
    I’ve never gotten sick from eating older canned/home-canned foods.

  • I join Tiffany in expressing my deepest Sympathy. I was also a fan & admirer of the great John Robbins…

  • Thank you for this great article. I also found out that some food like sardines, salmon and many other food in cans are either cooked in the cans or go through very high temperature to kill any bacteria ect. Therefore chemicals such as BPAs, could more easily leach into the food.

  • Thanks for this article. I learned a few things that I didn’t know
    before. I love canned beans for convivence in chili and the other
    recipes I make. I will be looking for canned items in glass
    containers now that I have read this article.

    Thanks Ocean. Sorry about your Dad. I was a big fan!!

    Tiffany Haynes, Arizona

  • I do not see “canned” tomatoes in glass where I shop. What are the pros/cons of aseptic packaging? I purchase broth/ soup and sometimes tomatoes in this type of packaging.

  • I freeze and can veggies and fruit from my garden every year and have for several years. I’m looking forward to the garden again this season.

  • I always use canned food including a lot of beans. This is new to me about what is in canned food.

  • >