Summary
Olive and avocado oils are widely used, popular ingredients worldwide. People often tout them for their health benefits and flavor. But they are also controversial and may not be of the quality that you think. Even the Mafia is in on it. Find out what you need to know about olive and avocado oil.
Where’s the oil in your kitchen? Next to the stove, maybe, or on a shelf with the baking supplies? I’m guessing it’s not the most thought-provoking ingredient in your pantry. You buy a bottle that says “extra virgin olive oil” or “avocado oil,” and naturally assume that’s what’s inside.
That assumption doesn’t always hold. When researchers tested oils bought from grocery stores and supermarkets, they found a range of problems: oil that has gone stale before its printed expiration date, oil sold as a higher grade than it is, oil blended with cheaper oils, and, now and then, oil that isn’t the stated oil at all.
Let’s explore how widespread the problem is, why it persists, and how to choose a bottle you can trust. And since there’s a vocal “no-oil” segment of the nutrition community, we’ll also look at whether these oils belong in your kitchen at all.
How Common Is “Oil Fraud”?
Let’s start with olive oil.
To earn the “extra virgin” label, olive oil must meet stringent standards, including a low level of free fatty acids, and pass a taste test showing no flavor defects.
UC Davis researchers tested olive oils sold in the U.S. around 2010 and found that over 60% of the imported ones were a lower grade than their labels claimed. A 2012 analysis of food fraud reports in scholarly journals named olive oil as one of the most commonly adulterated ingredients, with the other “winners” (a dubious title) including honey, saffron, and milk.
A 2017 FDA analysis of 88 bottles of extra virgin olive oil found that more than 60% could have been blended with cheaper oils, or were a lower grade of olive oil.
What about avocado oil?
Sadly, that industry looked at the olive oil shenanigans and said, “Hold my salad dressing.”
In 2020, UC Davis researchers reported that 15 of 22 name-brand avocado oils from stores and online retailers had gone rancid before their expiration date. Six were mixed with cheaper oils such as sunflower, safflower, or soybean. In 3 of those, the oil was nearly 100% soybean, meaning it contained almost no avocado. Unholy guacamole, Batman!
All told, at least 82% of the samples had one problem or the other. Generic store-brand avocado oil showed a similar pattern: A 2023 follow-up of 36 store-brand avocado oils found that 70% were either rancid or adulterated with other oils.
Rancid avocado oil doesn’t just taste off; it’s downright bad for you. Oxidized oils can produce reactive compounds that promote inflammation and oxidative damage, potentially harming your heart, liver, digestive system, and brain.
Why the Problem Persists
Many bottles of olive oil carry an Italian-sounding name or the words “Made in Italy” and claim to be extra virgin, cold-pressed, or 100% pure. Bottles with those claims on the label command higher prices. Sellers can increase their profits by making these claims while selling other, cheaper oils and lower grades of olive oil.
How profitable is such fraud? The head of Italy’s largest farmers association told the Financial Times that olive oil fraud margins can run as high as 700%, with profits that can exceed those from cocaine. Holy switcheroli, Batman!
But wait, aren’t there regulatory agencies that can protect us from oil fraud?
In the U.S., there’s no enforceable federal standard for what “extra virgin” means. The USDA’s grade standards are voluntary, and a petition filed in 2022 asking the FDA for a legal definition was still pending as of 2026.
California has stepped up to protect the integrity of its olive oil industry. California law bans the sale of “imitation olive oil” and requires anything labeled “California Olive Oil” to come entirely from California olives and meet state grade and labeling standards.
While regulation is anemic, enforcement is close to nonexistent. So a seller who cuts a pricey oil with a cheap one, or bottles last year’s oil as this year’s, faces little risk of being caught in the U.S.
Europe has stricter rules and more testing, and its enforcement record shows what the incentives produce:
- In December 2015, Italian authorities uncovered 7,000 tons of oil sold as “100% Italian” extra virgin that was actually blended from oils produced outside the EU.
- In 2017, Italian police arrested suspected members of a Mafia clan accused of crimes that included drug trafficking and exporting fake extra virgin olive oil to the U.S.
- In a 2024 operation coordinated by Europol, Italian authorities seized about 42 tons of contaminated oil, some of it already on the market as Italian extra virgin. Europol has described faking extra virgin olive oil as common practice.
Organized crime’s involvement in Italian agriculture is common enough that Italians have a name for it: the “agromafia.” Italy has responded by strengthening penalties and traceability requirements for olive oil fraud.
Should You Use Olive or Avocado Oil?

So now you know that a lot of olive and avocado oil out there isn’t what it claims to be. But what if you could be 100% confident that you were getting what you paid for? Should these oils be part of your diet?
The Case for Extra Virgin Olive Oil
Extra virgin olive oil (the real stuff!) is mostly monounsaturated fat and has less saturated fat than butter or tropical oils. About two-thirds of the fat in butter is saturated, while coconut oil is 80 to 90% saturated fat. Large amounts of saturated fat in your diet can raise your risk of high cholesterol, clogged arteries, and heart disease, and using monounsaturated oils instead of saturated fat can help lower LDL cholesterol.
Extra virgin olive oil is also rich in oleic acid and antioxidant polyphenols that may have anti-inflammatory effects.
Its heart-health evidence is the strongest of any oil. In PREDIMED, a large randomized trial of Spanish adults at high cardiovascular risk, a Mediterranean diet supplemented with about 4 tablespoons of extra virgin olive oil a day lowered the risk of major cardiovascular events, meaning heart attack, stroke, or cardiovascular death, compared with a control group advised to cut back on fat. The investigators later acknowledged that the control group never really did cut back on fat. Their fat intake drifted from 40% of calories to 37% over 5 years, which is not a low-fat diet by any standard.
A second Spanish trial, CORDIOPREV, tested the idea in people who already had heart disease. Researchers randomly assigned about 1,000 patients to a Mediterranean diet or a low-fat diet and followed them for 7 years. The Mediterranean group received free extra virgin olive oil each week and had roughly 25% fewer major cardiovascular events after adjusting for other factors. The benefit was clear in men, who made up most of the participants. Among the 175 women, no difference was found between the 2 diets.
Unlike PREDIMED’s comparison group, the low-fat group got a closely followed diet of its own, though one that still allowed up to 2 tablespoons of vegetable oil a day. (In the interest of full disclosure, funding came partly from the Fundación Patrimonio Comunal Olivarero, an olive oil sector foundation.)
Olive oil is also linked to a lower risk of dying from dementia in a large observational study, which shows association but not cause and effect. The evidence for type 2 diabetes and cancer is still preliminary.
What About Avocado Oil?

Avocado oil as a health food is a much thinner case. Like olive oil, it’s mostly monounsaturated fat, and using it in place of saturated fat can help lower LDL cholesterol. It also does one neat nutritional trick: Added to a salad, avocado oil markedly increases absorption of the carotenoids abundant in salad vegetables. (Avocado dressing bumps into salad. Now that’s what I call — get ready to groan — a “meet-cuke.”)
But there’s no PREDIMED equivalent for avocado oil, meaning no long-term trial tracking heart attacks, strokes, or deaths. Most avocado research looks at the whole fruit. A 2025 meta-analysis of 10 randomized trials found that eating avocados lowered LDL cholesterol and systolic blood pressure, though modestly: about 4 mg/dL for LDL and about 1 point for blood pressure. Whole avocados also bring fiber and other nutrients that the oil leaves behind.
So the case for avocado oil rests mostly on its fat profile, not on studies of health outcomes. And as you’ve seen, it’s the oil with the worst purity record. If you love avocados, the whole fruit is the better-supported choice. But that doesn’t mean it isn’t a healthy, or healthier, option. As researchers are fond of saying, more research is needed.
The Case for Going Without
Olive oil looks to be healthier than many other sources of fat. But is olive oil healthier than no oil at all? None of the above studies asked that specific question. So what’s the evidence cited by people who advocate an oil-free diet?
Blood Vessel Studies
Flow-mediated vasodilation is a measure of endothelial function; that is, how well arteries relax and widen when blood flow increases. Poorer vasodilation can raise long-term heart-disease risk.
Cardiologist Robert Vogel reported in 2000 that olive oil produced almost the same decline in flow-mediated vasodilation as did a fatty, heart-unfriendly fast-food breakfast.
That’s compelling, and it’s important to keep in mind that the studies Vogel conducted and cited measured a short-term effect over a few hours after a single meal, rather than actual heart attacks and strokes.
A bigger issue has been more recent research that complicates these early findings. A 2021 crossover trial found that high-polyphenolic extra virgin olive oil acutely enhanced endothelial function in the study cohort, whereas refined olive oil did not. This means the type and quality of oil matter, and blanket condemnations of all oils may not help.
Oil-Free Disease Reversal Interventions
First, programs exist to reverse heart disease. Some of the most impressive results come from programs that excluded added oil.
Dean Ornish published the results of his Lifestyle Heart Trial, a small randomized trial, in 1998. It found that coronary plaque regressed over five years in patients following a very low-fat vegetarian diet without added oil, while it progressed in the comparison group.
In a 2014 study from the Cleveland Clinic, Caldwell Esselstyn and colleagues followed 198 consecutive patient volunteers who received counseling to convert from their usual diet to one consisting entirely of whole, plant-based foods. Patients considered “adherent” were those who avoided all meat, fish, dairy, and, knowingly, any added oils (“knowingly” because there are many ways that oil can sneak into your diet, especially if you’re eating packaged or restaurant food).
The counseling was remarkably effective, because 177 patients were adherent, while only 21 were not. The diet was remarkably effective: Over an average of 3.7 years, only 1 of the 177 adherent patients (0.6%) had an adverse cardiac event (a stroke). By comparison, 13 of 21 nonadherent participants experienced adverse events (that’s 62%).
Dr. Esselstyn pointed out that the olive oil and nuts groups in PREDIMED achieved roughly a 30% reduction in cardiovascular events compared to the control group. In comparison, adherent patients in his study had more than a 99% reduction in risk compared with nonadherent patients.
At the same time, while Esselstyn’s results are remarkable, they don’t implicate oil as the unquestioned culprit in heart disease. The Esselstyn study wasn’t randomized. Its patients — 91% men, by the way, so it’s unclear whether the results apply to women — were volunteers motivated enough to seek out the program, while the comparison group was the small number who didn’t stick with it. It’s easy to imagine many other differences between these groups besides whether they knowingly consumed added oil.
Most critically, neither program isolated oil. They also removed meat, dairy, and processed foods, and Ornish’s program included exercise and stress management.
The Center for Nutrition Studies, a nonprofit that promotes whole food, plant-based eating, makes the same point that PREDIMED does not exonerate olive oil. Rather, it showed Mediterranean eating patterns lowered cardiovascular risk, but not that olive oil alone was responsible, since the experimental group that added nuts did about as well.
In a 2024 crossover trial, 40 adults at elevated cardiovascular risk followed whole food, plant-based diets with either about 4 tablespoons of extra virgin olive oil a day or less than a teaspoon, 4 weeks on each. Both diets significantly lowered LDL cholesterol, and in the main analysis the difference between them wasn’t statistically significant. The authors still favored the lower-oil diet because the order mattered: participants who ate the low-oil version first dropped their LDL significantly more, and those who switched from low oil to high saw it climb partway back. Four weeks is short, and the trial tracked blood markers rather than heart attacks or deaths.
Suggestive, but far from conclusive.
I do want to add a note of what I consider “common sense.” While some studies show health benefits of olive and avocado oils, they are still processed foods. All the fiber and many of the nutrients in the original food are gone, leaving one of the most calorie-dense foods there is: about 120 calories per tablespoon.
So for people who struggle to achieve and maintain a healthy weight, these high-calorie foods are probably not making things easier.
If you want to give oil-free living a try, you can find out more and get some delicious oil-free salad dressing recipes here.
An Overview of the Evidence

It seems clear at this point that replacing butter, margarine, and highly processed fats with extra virgin olive oil is an improvement. And that a whole food, plant-based eating pattern is generally a healthy one, whether it includes oil or not.
What remains unresolved is whether a modest amount of oil helps, harms, or makes no difference for someone already eating a healthy, whole food, plant-based diet. No long-term trial has followed people eating that way, with and without oil, and tracked heart attacks, strokes, or deaths. The only head-to-head trial lasted four weeks. Until that kind of study is done, we’re unlikely to know with certainty what’s best for whom.
Oil has become a dividing line in the plant-based world, and the debate often generates more heat than light. Some advocates treat oil as poison, others as a cornerstone of healthy eating, and arguments between the two camps can turn personal. I’d like to look at what the evidence actually shows, even when it complicates positions many passionate advocates hold dear.
One researcher who has examined these arguments closely is Roman Pawlak, a nutrition scientist at East Carolina University. In the interest of full disclosure (and as a point of pride), he is also a faculty member in Food Revolution Network’s Nutrition and Lifestyle Coaching Certificate program.
In a 2026 review in Nutrition Today, he took on 10 common arguments for avoiding extra virgin olive oil in whole food, plant-based diets, including its calorie density, its saturated fat content, and the idea that it harms blood vessels. He concluded that none of those arguments is supported by the broader research, and noted that people who eat this way generally have low cardiovascular risk to begin with.
It’s one researcher’s review, not a trial comparing oil-free eating with eating olive oil, and much of the evidence it relies on is observational. Still, it suggests that a modest amount of olive oil in an otherwise healthy dietary pattern may have benefits, and is unlikely to do harm.
So where does that leave you? If you already eat mostly whole plant foods and don’t miss oil, the evidence gives you no reason to start. If you enjoy a drizzle of olive oil on your salad, it gives you no strong reason to stop. And if you’re living with heart disease, both approaches have evidence behind them: oil-free programs that reported plaque regression, and CORDIOPREV, which found fewer cardiovascular events with an olive oil-rich Mediterranean diet.
If you’re living with heart disease, or taking medication for cholesterol or blood pressure, this is worth talking through with your healthcare provider rather than settling it from an article. They know your numbers, and a real change in how you eat is worth tracking alongside someone who’s watching them.
There’s one more wrinkle. The studies showing benefits from olive oil used genuine, high-quality extra virgin olive oil, which brings us back to what’s in your kitchen.
Does Fraud Tip the Balance Against Olive Oil?
The trials that found benefits from olive oil made sure participants were getting the real thing. In PREDIMED, participants in the Mediterranean diet groups received either extra virgin olive oil (approximately 1 liter per week) or mixed nuts at no cost. The researchers even checked participants’ urine for hydroxytyrosol, a polyphenol found in extra virgin olive oil, to confirm they were actually consuming it. CORDIOPREV also supplied its Mediterranean diet group with extra virgin olive oil.
That matters because many of the benefits credited to extra virgin olive oil are linked to its polyphenols, and polyphenol content depends on quality and freshness. Remember the 2021 crossover trial: High-polyphenol extra virgin olive oil improved blood vessel function after a meal, while refined olive oil did not. Oxidized oil loses its flavor and health benefits.
Now recall the testing. In the FDA’s analysis, more than 60% of bottles labeled extra virgin failed at least one authenticity test. Most of the avocado oils UC Davis tested were rancid, blended, or both. The oil on a typical supermarket shelf may have little in common with the oil that trial participants received, and unless you happen to have a hydroxytyrosol test kit handy to check your pee, you have no way of knowing whether you’re still getting any of those polyphenols.
So if you do use oil, the buying tips below aren’t just about getting your money’s worth. They’re also about getting the high-quality oil used in the studies that found protective effects. If you can’t verify what you’re buying, you might just be adding a calorie-dense, processed food that provides no cardiovascular protection and may actually be doing harm.
So we’re back to a point raised by the “oil-free” advocates: The most surefire way to avoid fraudulent oil is to skip added oil altogether, and get your fats from whole foods like avocados, nuts, and seeds.
If you’d rather keep some olive or avocado oil in your kitchen, here’s how to improve your odds of getting the real thing.
How to Choose an Oil You Can Trust
No single label or price point guarantees you’re getting the real thing. But a few habits can tilt the odds strongly in your favor.
Olive Oil
When choosing an olive oil:
- Look for a harvest or pressing date. This tells you how fresh the oil is, which a “best by” date doesn’t. The UC Davis Olive Center suggests using olive oil within 15 to 18 months of harvest, and within a couple of months of opening the bottle.
- Look for quality seals or certified origin. Options include the EU’s PDO and PGI designations, the California Olive Oil Council’s (COOC) 100% Certified Extra Virgin seal, and the North American Olive Oil Association’s NAOOA Certified Oil program, which carries a red circular logo with a green olive branch. (NAOOA is an industry trade group.) None of these guarantees anything, but each involves some outside testing or oversight.
- Choose dark glass or tins. Light speeds up oxidation, so avoid oils sold in clear containers.
- Be wary of bargains. If a bottle of extra virgin olive oil seems too cheap to be real, it may well be. You don’t need to buy the most expensive bottle on the shelf, but the cheapest is probably not a reliable choice.
- Consider organic. Organic certification reduces your exposure to pesticides. It doesn’t verify that the oil is pure or fresh, so it’s no substitute for the other checks on this list.
- Taste it if you can. Good extra virgin olive oil should taste fruity at the front of your mouth and peppery at the back of your throat. That peppery bite comes partly from polyphenols. Oil that tastes flat, greasy, or like crayons has likely gone rancid. (If that last tip was extremely valuable for you, maybe we should publish an article titled “Don’t Eat Crayons.”)
Avocado Oil
Avocado oil has no enforceable U.S. standards, so you have even less to go on. When choosing an avocado oil:
- Check the harvest or production date. As with olive oil, the “best before” date isn’t a reliable quality indicator.
- Know what the color tells you, and what it doesn’t. Virgin (unrefined) avocado oil should be green, while refined avocado oil is light yellow and almost clear. Color tells you the grade, not whether the oil is pure: In its 2020 study, UC Davis found that the only two brands it deemed pure and unoxidized were both refined.
- Use your nose and taste buds. Fresh virgin avocado oil tastes grassy and buttery, a bit like mushrooms. Rancid avocado oil smells stale, almost like Play-Doh.
- Opt for organic and fair-trade when possible, to reduce pesticide exposure and support better labor practices in the industry.
Once It’s Home
Even genuine, fresh oil degrades with light, heat, and air. Buy bottles small enough to finish within a couple of months, keep the cap closed, and store them in a cool, dark cupboard. Next to the stove might be convenient, but heat and light may hasten degradation.
Beyond the Bottle: Environmental and Human Costs

While this article is mostly about whether olive and avocado oil is good for you, I don’t want to leave out the external costs to the environment and the people tasked with growing and harvesting the fruits.
Avocados
U.S. avocado consumption roughly tripled between 2000 and 2021, and imports now supply about 90% of the U.S. market. Mexico supplied 88% of shipments from 2019 to 2021. Most of that fruit comes from one state, Michoacán.
A 2022 review in Ambio linked avocado expansion there to deforestation and forest fragmentation, affecting biodiversity, soil, and water. A 2026 study found soil moisture declining across the region’s avocado belt between 2001 and 2018. However, a regional producers’ association says future studies should distinguish between older and newer orchards and different growing practices. The same Ambio review found the industry has also created jobs and reduced poverty and out-migration, though inequity in the region limits those benefits.
As with Italian olive oil, organized crime is part of the picture. A 2024 report from the Global Initiative Against Transnational Organized Crime described ties between public authorities, local elites, and criminal groups in Michoacán’s avocado boom, as well as widespread extortion along the supply chain.
It cited official sources saying about 80% of the state’s avocado orchards were established illegally. U.S. inspectors who check fruit in the state have also been targeted: CNN reported that imports from Michoacán were paused in 2022 after an inspector received a threatening phone call, and again in 2024 after 2 inspectors were detained and assaulted.
Olive Oil
Olive oil has its own problems. Much of Spain’s olive land is in traditional groves with deep roots that can be centuries old. Newer super-high-density groves have shallow roots, depend on continuous drip irrigation, and last about 14 to 16 years. Spanish researchers have warned that heavy irrigation in dry regions is straining groundwater and contributing to desertification.
Labor is a concern too. Migrant workers harvesting olives in Sicily through gangmasters are paid as little as $2 an hour and live in shacks without running water.
What You Can Do
If these costs matter to you, a few steps are within reach: use less, choose oil and fruit from producers you can learn about, and ask retailers where their products come from. Small producers who print a harvest date and name their groves tend to be easier to trace, which happens to be one of the same habits that protects you from fraud.
The Bottom Line

Much of the olive and avocado oil sold in the U.S. and around the world may not match its label. Outright fakes seem less common than stale, lower-grade, or blended oil, but with weak regulation and little enforcement, shoppers have few protections. Avocado oil, with no enforceable standards, inspires even less confidence.
Genuine extra virgin olive oil has solid evidence behind it as a replacement for butter, margarine, and other less healthy fats. Whether it enhances an already healthy whole food, plant-based diet is still an open question, and avocado oil’s case rests mostly on its fat profile rather than studies of health outcomes. Either way, the benefits seen in research came from high-quality oil, which isn’t guaranteed by what’s printed on the bottle.
So you have two reasonable paths. If you use oil, buy it carefully: look for a harvest date and a credible seal, store it well, and use it up while it’s fresh. Or skip added oil and get your fats from whole foods, avocados, nuts, and seeds. Either way, it’s good to know what you’re getting.
Fresh Pressed Olive Oil Club specializes in exceptional, freshly harvested olive oils from small artisanal producers around the world. By sourcing from the Northern and Southern Hemispheres at different times of year, the club delivers fresh, seasonal oils through a quarterly subscription. While the oils aren’t certified organic, the club offers an appealing way to discover distinctive varieties from different regions. Click here to learn more.
If you make a purchase through either link, the company will contribute a portion of the proceeds to support Food Revolution Network’s mission. (Thank you!)
Tell us in the comments:
- Do you use vegetable oils? If so, what is your go-to kind, and how do you like to use it?
- Because of food fraud in the bottled vegetable oil industry, will you change any of your purchasing decisions going forward?
- Would you consider going oil-free, or have you ever tried making oil-free recipes?
Feature image: iStock.com/MEDITERRANEAN